Barbastelles call quietly, 10 to 100 times lower in amplitude than other aerial hawking bats, and Kaleidoscope only detects a pulse about 12 dB above the background. A file with fewer detected pulses than the minimum you set is filed as noise, so a faint or short barbastelle pass can end up there. Check your signal settings and a random sample of noise, and open recordings that also hold a louder species. Running the same files through a second classifier also helps: BioSonic can name up to seven species in one recording.

We make BioSonic. The method on this page works with any bat analysis software.

Why it happens

CauseWhat the source saysWhat to do
Quiet callsBarbastelle calls are 10 to 100 times lower in amplitude than those of other aerial hawking bats (Goerlitz et al. 2010).Place detectors on flight paths, where BCT notes calls may be stronger.
Detection thresholdKaleidoscope needs a signal about 12 dB above the background, and a faint call that you can see may fall below it.Open the zero-crossing view to see which pulses were detected.
Too few pulsesFiles with fewer pulses than the minimum number of pulses are labelled noise.Try a lower minimum on one night and compare. Expect more false triggers.
A louder bat in the same fileBCT warns that barbastelle can be lost when software names only one species per recording, because the louder calls win.Open files with loud pipistrelles or noctules on nights when barbastelle is expected, or use software that returns several species per file.

The link between these settings and barbastelle in the noise folder is our reading of the user guide and the research. We found no study that measured how often it happens.

What to do with a survey you have already analysed

  1. Pick the detectors and nights where barbastelle is most likely.
  2. Check a random sample of their noise files on the spectrogram.
  3. Run those nights again with changed settings, or in a second program, and compare file by file.
  4. Have an experienced analyst confirm every barbastelle record you report.
  5. Write down the software version, the settings and what you found.

In BioSonic

BioSonic gives up to seven species per recording and a confidence for each identification. You can show the files it marked as noise, open them and correct them. It can also miss a faint call, so the same check applies.

Common question

Can auto ID identify barbastelle reliably?

BCT says auto ID can usually identify barbastelle readily, depending on call quality and the software. The risk is calls that are too faint to detect, or hidden behind a louder species in the same recording.

Sources

Related: How much of the noise folder to check · Kaleidoscope Pro alternatives · Published classifier accuracy tests