---
canonical: https://biosonic.io/compare/ecoobs-batident
---

# BioSonic vs ecoObs batIdent and bcAdmin

Last updated: 2026-11-17. Written by the BioSonic team.

batIdent, bcAdmin and bcAnalyze are the Mac analysis software of the batcorder system, made by ecoObs GmbH in Nuremberg, Germany, and built around batcorder recorders for static surveys and nacelle monitoring (Gondelmonitoring) at wind turbines. BioSonic is a Swedish cloud platform that identifies European bat species from bat detector recordings (WAV, FLAC or Anabat zero-crossing) and lets a whole team review the results in the browser. Choose the ecoObs system if you record with batcorders and need a ProBat-compatible nacelle workflow, curtailment checks and offline work on a Mac; choose BioSonic for team review in the browser, automatic behaviour labels and up to 7 species per recording across mixed detector brands, and use both if you want a second, independent species review of exported batcorder nights.

The ecoObs system is hardware and software designed together. BioSonic is software only. This page sets out what each does, where each is the better fit, and how they can work side by side.

## At a glance

Facts about the ecoObs software come from ecoObs's own pages and manuals, linked in the references. Where we could not verify something, we say so.

| Feature | BioSonic | ecoObs bcAdmin and batIdent |
|---|---|---|
| Made by | Biosonic AB, Stockholm, Sweden (founded February 2024) | ecoObs GmbH, Nuremberg, Germany [3] |
| What it is | One cloud platform: automatic species ID, review and reporting in the browser | Mac apps: bcAdmin 4 (database, call finder, AI species identifier, analysis), batIdent (older statistical identifier) and bcAnalyze 4 (manual call analysis) [1] |
| Hardware | Software only; works with WAV and FLAC from many full-spectrum detector brands, plus Anabat zero-crossing files | Designed together with the batcorder 3.1 and GSM-batcorder; bcAdmin is cheaper for batcorder buyers [5][8] |
| Where it runs | Any modern web browser; analysis on BioSonic's servers in the EU | macOS 12 or newer, Intel or Apple silicon Mac; no Windows version listed [1] |
| File formats | WAV and FLAC, plus Anabat zero-crossing; for batcorder .raw files, ask BioSonic first | bcAdmin: batcorder raw and WAV. bcAnalyze: raw, WAV, MP3 and FLAC [1][2] |
| Identification method | Deep learning on spectrograms, trained on 2.5 million verified bat calls and 3.5 million noise files | Call finder measures every call; batIdent uses random forest and kernel methods in R; the newer CoreML identifier works per call with probability thresholds (80% by default) [2][3] |
| Species per recording | Up to 7 | Up to 3 [2][3] |
| Behaviour | Echolocation, feeding buzzes and social calls separated automatically | Identification is not trained for social calls apart from Pipistrelloid social calls [7] |
| Accuracy evidence | 98.7% F1 in a third-party benchmark (Wilder Sensing, 5,325 predictions), ranked first of the classifiers tested [11] | No published figure found on ecoObs's pages; no head-to-head test with BioSonic |
| Wind turbine tools | Species and behaviour ID, dated CSV and Excel export; no curtailment calculation; not a ProBat-validated workflow | Wind and temperature correlation, curtailment analysis, ProBat data validation; the batcorder is one of the recorders ProBat 7 works with [2][9] |
| Team work | Whole team in shared projects on one organisation account; every change attributed | Licence runs on one Mac at a time; extra licences available; database files on your disk [2] |
| Data storage | Stored in the EU, mainly in Sweden; recordings kept for 9 years | On your own Mac or network drive |
| Pricing model | Package of analysis GB, lower price per GB for bigger packages; ask us for a quote; no per-seat fees | bcAdmin: annual licence for the calendar year; batIdent: free; bcAnalyze: Mac App Store [5][6] |
| Model updates | New model trained and deployed every weekend | Software updates on an irregular basis, included while your licence year runs [2] |

## Who should choose which

These tools overlap on automatic species ID, but the ecoObs system also covers recording hardware and wind turbine analysis that BioSonic does not try to do.

### The ecoObs system is the better fit if you

- Record with batcorders or GSM-batcorders and want software designed for their raw files and log files [2]
- Run Gondelmonitoring where the permit requires ProBat, and want ProBat data validation, wind and temperature correlation and curtailment checks in the same app [2][9]
- Want to work offline on your own Mac, with recordings on your own disks
- Like to see the measured call parameters behind each identification
- Prefer a licence that keeps the app running after the year ends, even without updates [6]

### BioSonic is the better fit if you

- Work as a team and want everyone in the same projects without per-seat fees
- Use Windows PCs, or a mix of computers
- Record with mixed detectors: Batlogger, Song Meter, AudioMoth, Anabat, Pettersson
- Want feeding buzzes and social calls flagged automatically, and up to 7 species per recording
- Want third-party accuracy evidence: 98.7% F1 in the Wilder Sensing benchmark
- Prefer no software to install or maintain, with recordings kept in the EU for up to 9 years

## How each tool works

### ecoObs: a recorder, a database and a call-by-call identifier

ecoObs builds the batcorder, a recorder that samples at 500 kHz with 16-bit resolution and triggers on call quality in real time, and the GSM-batcorder, which records continuously at nacelle height on wind turbines and sends a daily status message by SMS. [8] The analysis side is a set of Mac apps. bcAdmin 4 is the hub: it imports batcorder log files and SD cards into sessions, stores everything in database files, runs an automatic call finder that measures every call, and produces activity reports, plots and CSV exports. [2] ecoObs says it is optimised for batcorder recordings but works with files of other systems too, and some features need data only the batcorder produces. [2]

Species identification has two generations. batIdent is a free, open-source app that uses the statistical tools R, randomForest and kernlab on the call measurements, starting at genus or group level (for example Nyctaloid, Pipistrelloid, Myotis) and moving to species when the data allows, with Plecotus kept at genus level. [3] Since bcAdmin 4 version 1.4 there is also a built-in CoreML identifier, which ecoObs says will replace batIdent, runs about five times faster and lets you set probability thresholds per genus and species. [2][4] Either way, a recording gets at most three species. [2] For manual work, bcAnalyze 4 gives high-resolution sonagrams and call analysis. [1]

### BioSonic: automatic identification in the cloud

BioSonic converts each WAV recording into a spectrogram and runs it through deep neural networks trained on more than 2.5 million verified bat calls and 3.5 million noise files from across Europe, curated by 12 bat experts. It returns species with a confidence score, can find up to 7 species in one recording, and separates echolocation, feeding buzzes and social calls. The noise model rejects rain, wind, insects and equipment noise before results reach you.

Everything happens in the browser. You upload recordings, the analysis runs on our servers, and your team reviews spectrograms, confirms or overrides calls, and exports charts, maps, Word reports or CSV and Excel files with the date and time of every identified recording. A new model is trained and deployed every weekend, so nobody has to install updates. BioSonic covers German bat species and is used by teams in the UK, Netherlands, Denmark, Germany and Sweden.

## Accuracy and evidence

BioSonic scored 98.7% F1 in a third-party benchmark by Wilder Sensing on 5,325 predictions, ranked first of the classifiers tested. The method and confusion matrices are on our [benchmarks page](https://biosonic.io/benchmarks). [11]

batIdent and the CoreML identifier in bcAdmin were not part of that benchmark, we found no accuracy figure on ecoObs's own pages, and we know of no published head-to-head test between them and BioSonic. So we will not claim one tool is more accurate than the other. If you want an answer for your own sites, run the same set of verified recordings through both and compare. We are happy to help with that.

Both companies agree on one thing: automatic results need checking. ecoObs's own guide to automatic call analysis walks through how to revise results manually, and says neither automatic nor manual analysis can guarantee absolute reliability. [10] With BioSonic, Myotis to species and Plecotus need manual verification by an experienced ecologist, and the confidence scores are there to send your checking time to the calls that need it.

## Workflow fit: replace, or use both?

If you own batcorders, you do not have to choose. A practical split looks like this:

1. Keep recording with your batcorders and import the SD cards or log files into bcAdmin as usual.
2. Keep bcAdmin for anything tied to the batcorder system or ProBat: session management, nacelle data, wind and temperature correlation and curtailment checks.
3. Export the nights you want a second opinion on as WAV with Recordings > Save as Wave, which the bcAdmin 4 manual describes for sharing batcorder files with people who cannot open raw recordings. [2]
4. Upload the WAV files to BioSonic. Noise is filtered out and every bat pass is sorted by species and behaviour with a confidence score, ready for the team to review in the browser.
5. Check the hard calls (Myotis, Plecotus, low confidence) by hand, in BioSonic's spectrograms or in bcAnalyze.

Teams that run batcorders next to other brands, for example Batlogger or AudioMoth units added for a large static survey, can also use BioSonic as the one place where every detector's WAV files are sorted the same way.

The batcorder is not on BioSonic's published detector list. WAV exports upload like any other WAV; if you would rather upload the batcorder .raw files directly, ask BioSonic first. Either way, try one sample night before you move a whole project. See [detector compatibility](https://biosonic.io/bat-detector-compatibility) for what to upload from each detector.

## Wind turbines, ProBat and German survey work

In Germany, nacelle monitoring at wind turbines (Gondelmonitoring) usually feeds ProBat, the free tool that calculates bat-friendly cut-in wind speeds (Abschaltalgorithmen) for onshore turbines. The BfN describes ProBat 7 as a recognised standard that Bavaria, Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania and North Rhine-Westphalia already prescribe in their wind energy guidance, and says it works with Anabat, batcorder and Avisoft recorders. [9] bcAdmin adds a ProBat data validation step, correlation of bat activity with wind speed and temperature, and a curtailment analysis that checks whether recordings fall inside or outside a set of curtailment conditions. [2] For this job the ecoObs system is the established route, and we would not suggest replacing it.

BioSonic does not run ProBat or implement the RENEBAT models, is not a ProBat-validated workflow, and does not calculate fatalities, cut-in wind speeds or curtailment schedules. What it does for wind projects is species identification and behaviour classification on large continuous datasets from nacelle and ground detectors, plus a CSV or Excel export of every identified recording with its date and time, so you can combine it with the turbine's own 10-minute wind and temperature data. More on our [wind farm bat monitoring page](https://biosonic.io/wind-farm-bat-monitoring).

For ground surveys, such as static detectors (Horchboxen) for a species protection assessment (spezielle artenschutzrechtliche Prüfung, saP), the question is simpler: which tool sorts your recordings by species fastest, with results your team can check and defend. That is where a side-by-side test on your own data is most useful.

## Detectors and file formats

**BioSonic** accepts WAV and FLAC files and reads them directly as recorded, with no conversion, from Batlogger (Elekon), AudioMoth, Wildlife Acoustics Song Meter (including the SM4) and Echo Meter, Pettersson, Titley Anabat and Dodotronic Ultramic. It also accepts Anabat zero-crossing files. For batcorder recordings, upload WAV exported from bcAdmin, or ask BioSonic first about the batcorder .raw files.

**bcAdmin 4** supports raw and WAV files only. Besides batcorder recordings it can analyse files from other real-time bat detectors, has an import for Batlogger WAV folders, and can read recording times from SM2Bat and Avisoft file names. [2][6] ecoObs recommends at least 350 kHz sample rate (500 kHz preferred) and 16-bit resolution for files from other systems, and warns that recordings with echoes or low sound quality can give weaker automatic measurements. [2][6] **bcAnalyze 4** also opens MP3 and FLAC. [1]

## Pricing model in words

**BioSonic** is sold as a package of analysis gigabytes. The bigger the package, the lower the price per GB. There are no per-seat fees: your whole team works on one organisation account, and your recordings are kept in the EU for up to 9 years. [Ask us for a quote](mailto:josef.carlson@biosonic.se) for your volume.

**ecoObs** sells bcAdmin 4 as an annual licence, with a reduced price for buyers of a batcorder 3, a GSM-batcorder or at least five Mini-batcorders, and additional licences for existing customers. [5] The licence is valid for the calendar year you buy it in; after that the app keeps running, but updates and support are no longer free. [6] batIdent (including batIdentCoreML) is a free download, and bcAnalyze 4 is sold only through the Mac App Store. [5] Check ecoObs's price list for current figures.

## Data and collaboration

**BioSonic** keeps recordings and results in the EU, mainly in Sweden, with uploaded audio in encrypted cloud storage. Everyone in your organisation logs in to the same projects, and every confirmation or override is attributed to the reviewer, which gives you an audit trail for reports. You can export your data at any time. See our [security page](https://biosonic.io/security) for details.

**bcAdmin** keeps its database in SQLite files on your Mac, with the recordings stored beside them on disk, so your data never leaves your own hardware. [2] The licence is registered to a name and email address, needs an internet check about once a week, and runs on one Mac at a time; you can move it between Macs or buy additional licences. [2] Locations and species lists can be shared through a central store. [2] If several people need to work on the same database, ask ecoObs how they recommend setting that up.

## Frequently asked questions

### Can BioSonic analyse batcorder recordings?

Yes, and the simplest route is WAV. The batcorder saves recordings in its own .raw format, and bcAdmin can export them as WAV with Recordings > Save as Wave, which the bcAdmin 4 manual describes for sending batcorder files to someone who cannot open raw recordings. [2] If you would rather upload the batcorder .raw files directly, ask BioSonic first. The batcorder is not on BioSonic's published detector list, so try one sample night before you move a whole project.

### Can BioSonic replace bcAdmin for ProBat Gondelmonitoring at wind turbines?

No. If your permit calls for ProBat, keep a ProBat-compatible recorder and workflow: the German Federal Agency for Nature Conservation (BfN) says ProBat 7 works with Anabat, batcorder and Avisoft recorders, and bcAdmin has a ProBat data validation step, wind and temperature correlation and a curtailment check. [2][9] BioSonic does not run ProBat, is not a ProBat-validated workflow and does not calculate cut-in wind speeds or curtailment schedules. It can sit alongside as a species and behaviour review of the same recordings exported as WAV.

### Which is more accurate, batIdent or BioSonic?

Nobody has published a head-to-head test, so we cannot honestly say. BioSonic scored 98.7% F1 in a third-party benchmark (Wilder Sensing, 5,325 predictions), ranked first of the classifiers tested. [11] batIdent and the newer CoreML identifier in bcAdmin were not part of that test, and we found no accuracy figure on ecoObs's own pages. The fair test is to run the same verified recordings through both.

### Do we get the program ourselves, like bcAdmin, or does BioSonic run the analysis?

BioSonic runs the analysis for you. You upload WAV files in the browser, the analysis runs on BioSonic's servers in the EU, and your team reviews and exports results online, so there is nothing to install. bcAdmin, batIdent and bcAnalyze are apps you install on your own Mac, and your recordings and database stay on your own disks.

### Is BioSonic a licence that renews each year, or is it based on gigabytes?

BioSonic is based on gigabytes: you buy a package of analysis gigabytes, and the bigger the package, the lower the price per GB. There are no per-seat fees and your whole team is on one organisation account. ecoObs sells bcAdmin 4 as an annual licence that covers the calendar year you buy it in, with a reduced price for batcorder customers; batIdent is a free download and bcAnalyze is sold through the Mac App Store. [5][6]

### Can multiple users work at the same time?

In BioSonic, yes: everyone in your organisation works in the same projects in the browser, and every confirmation or change is attributed to the reviewer. The bcAdmin 4 manual says a licence runs on one Mac at a time, can be moved between Macs, and that you can buy additional licences; its database files live on your own disk. [2] Check with ecoObs how they recommend a team shares one database.

### Would BioSonic negate manual analysis?

No. BioSonic does the bulk sorting and gives every call a confidence score, but Myotis to species and Plecotus always need manual verification by an experienced ecologist, and ecoObs gives the same advice about checking its own automatic results. [10] You can keep bcAnalyze or the bcAdmin file browser for detailed call checks and use BioSonic to shrink the pile you have to check.

### We use Windows PCs. Can we use BioSonic or bcAdmin?

BioSonic, yes: it runs in a modern web browser on Windows, macOS or Linux. ecoObs lists macOS 12 or newer on an Intel or Apple silicon Mac as the requirement for bcAdmin 4 and bcAnalyze 4, and we found no Windows version listed, so check with ecoObs if you need one. [1]

## References

1. ecoObs, [Software overview](https://ecoobs.com/soft-ueber.html): bcAdmin 4 as recording database, automatic call finder, AI species identifier and data analysis; bcAnalyze 4 for manual call analysis; formats (raw, WAV, MP3, FLAC); macOS 12 or newer on Intel or M-series Macs. Accessed 2026-11-17.
2. ecoObs, [Manual bcAdmin 4.0, version 1.6 (April 2026)](https://ecoobs.com/downloads/manual-for-bcadmin-4.pdf): works best with batcorder files, raw and WAV only, Batlogger import; up to three species per recording; CoreML identifier from version 1.4 with probability thresholds; Save as Wave export; CSV export; environmental correlation, ProBat data validation and curtailment analysis; licensing on one Mac at a time with additional licences. Accessed 2026-11-17.
3. ecoObs, [batIdent manual, version 1.5](https://ecoobs.com/downloads/Manual-batIdent.pdf): free software under the GNU GPL; needs R with randomForest and kernlab; built-in species and groups; one to three species per recording; ecoObs GmbH, Nuremberg. Accessed 2026-11-17.
4. ecoObs, [CoreML 2025](https://ecoobs.com/news/coreml2025.html) (8 March 2025): bcAdmin 4 version 1.5.1 brings the first reworked release of the CoreML identifier, which ecoObs recommends switching to. Accessed 2026-11-17.
5. ecoObs, [Prices](https://ecoobs.com/preise.html): bcAdmin 4 annual licence with a reduced price for batcorder customers and additional licences; batIdentCoreML free; bcAnalyze 4 only through the App Store. Accessed 2026-11-17.
6. ecoObs, [bcAdmin 4](https://ecoobs.com/bcAdmin.html): analyses files from other real-time detectors; recommended 350 to 500 kHz and 16 bit; activity reports and wind turbine plots; licence valid for the calendar year, app keeps running afterwards without free updates or support. Accessed 2026-11-17.
7. ecoObs, [Questions and answers](https://ecoobs.com/funda.html): identification algorithms are not trained for social calls apart from Pipistrelloid social calls. Accessed 2026-11-17.
8. ecoObs, [batcorder 3.1](https://ecoobs.com/batcorder.html) (500 kHz, 16 bit, trigger by call quality) and [GSM-batcorder](https://ecoobs.com/gsm-batcorder.html) (continuous recording at nacelle height, daily SMS status). Accessed 2026-11-17.
9. Bundesamt für Naturschutz (BfN), [PraxisInfo 1: ProBat 7](https://epflicht.ulb.uni-bonn.de/download/pdf/782600): ProBat 7 calculates bat-friendly cut-in wind speeds for onshore turbines, is prescribed in the wind energy guidance of Bavaria, Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania and North Rhine-Westphalia, and works with Anabat, batcorder and Avisoft recorders. See also [probat.org](https://www.probat.org/). Accessed 2026-11-17.
10. Marckmann, U. and Runkel, V., ecoObs, [Automatic bat call analysis with the batcorder system, version 1.02 (2010)](https://ecoobs.com/downloads/howto-automatic-bat-call-analysis-with-the-batcorder-system.pdf): options and advice for manual revision of automatic results. Accessed 2026-11-17.
11. Wilder Sensing, third-party benchmark, 5,325 predictions: BioSonic 98.7% F1, ranked first of the classifiers tested. [biosonic.io/benchmarks](https://biosonic.io/benchmarks).

BioSonic facts come from our [FAQ](https://biosonic.io/faq), [security page](https://biosonic.io/security) and [wind farm bat monitoring page](https://biosonic.io/wind-farm-bat-monitoring). Last verified: 2026-11-17.

Prefer another language? [Fledermausrufe analysieren](https://biosonic.io/de/fledermausrufe-analyse) explains BioSonic for German bat surveys and Gondelmonitoring, in German.

## Other comparisons

- [BioSonic vs BatExplorer](https://biosonic.io/compare/batexplorer): any detector vs Elekon's Windows desktop tool for Batlogger users.
- [BioSonic vs Kaleidoscope Pro](https://biosonic.io/compare/kaleidoscope): cloud AI and team review vs a desktop classifier, compared on the same third-party benchmark.
- [BioSonic vs SonoBat UK](https://biosonic.io/compare/sonobat): cloud species ID for Europe vs a long-standing desktop vetting tool.
- [See all comparisons](https://biosonic.io/compare)

## See how BioSonic handles your recordings

Export a few batcorder nights as WAV, or upload WAVs from any other detector, and compare the results with your current workflow. No commitment, no installation required.

[Start free trial](https://bat.biosonic.se/signup) | [Book a demo](https://cal.com/biosonic/30min)

Questions? Email [josef.carlson@biosonic.se](mailto:josef.carlson@biosonic.se)
